It's a weak circumstantial case, and at the very least, I think an appellate court should review it,

It was reinstated by the appellate court in Brooklyn.

We do have that case up for review.

I think the court is going to have to take it. This is a vital case on the principle of an American citizen captured in the United States and what constitutional rights does he have.

at least provides some judicial review.

None of the legal issues presented by this case seems to warrant Supreme Court review.